Summary. Adel Taarabt: Failed to score a league goal for Fulham from 29 attempts this season, but netted with his first shot for Milan— WhoScored.com Taarabt represented France at under-16, under-17 and under-18 levels,[54] but opted to play for Morocco at senior level, saying, "I felt the time was right when I was given this opportunity". He stated he wished he had signed for Arsenal instead but had opted for Spurs after Damien Comolli moved from being a scout at Arsenal to director of football at Spurs. Adel Taarabt (Berber: ⴰⴷⵉⵍ ⵜⴰⵖⵔⴰⴱⵜ; born 24 May 1989) is a Moroccan professional footballer who plays as an attacking midfielder or winger for Portuguese club Benfica and the Morocco national team.. Taarabt began his playing career in France at Lens before moving to English Premier League club Tottenham Hotspur in 2007. He's not fit. I have contact with good teams and I know that they want me. I will be sad if he ends up going to make some money because I think he has great ability. He collected the ball on his chest inside the QPR half, dribbled 20 yards past three players and curled in a shot from 25 yards. [15], On 23 July 2009, Taarabt rejoined QPR on a season-long loan for the 2009–10 season. [38] He made his Fulham debut in an away match against Sunderland, where he played the full 90 minutes. Some notable moments during the season were against Cardiff City (an away 2–2 draw), where Taarabt picked up a brace, scoring a wonder goal in the process. [63] His parents are natives of the Rif region, near Taza. He made his return as a substitute in a friendly match against Burkina Faso on 6 September. However, much will be made of the impressive performances and impact of the players to grace the Premier League for the first time this weekend. This was a mistake and I regret it. [25], These factors had the unfortunate effect of unsettling Taarabt and he was unable to recreate his form from the previous season. Adel Taarabt is a doubt due to an ankle injury and joins Alejandro Grimaldo as an injury concern. Statistics. "[46], On 12 June 2015, Taarabt signed a five-year contract with Portuguese champions Benfica on €4 million transfer fee. Nationality: Morocco. Taarabt was omitted from Morocco's squad for the 2013 Africa Cup of Nations by head coach Rachid Taoussi. 11.53am GMT "I'm very excited to see Arsenal being linked with Kim Kallstrom," he writes. " Tottenham tried to do it like Arsenal but it's a different culture. Adel can always make money but he is better than that. Trending News & Rumors for Football, Basketball, Baseball, Hockey, Soccer & More Check out Adel Taarabt's FIFA 19 rating predictions by Futhead using WhoScored ratings! Adel Taarabt, 31, from Morocco SL Benfica, since 2018 Attacking Midfield Market value: €4.00m * May 24, 1989 in Fes, Morocco QPR have only ever lost once at home to Tottenham in Premier League history. Now I just have to hope they can agree a deal with Tottenham. Adel Taarabt had the world at his feet. Adel Taarabt has been described as "mercurial but inconsistent" by BBC columnist Paul Fletcher, whereas former manager Neil Warncok opted for "talented, exciting and frustrating" (via BBC). [19], In March 2010, Taarabt was quoted in an interview as being sorry he had signed for Tottenham, saying, "The big mistake was to sign for Tottenham and not go to another club when I first came over." Will Adel Taarabt (another former Spurs employee) prove yet again to be the difference in this fixture or will it be one of the other 4 former Tottenham players? He was also shown his first red card in English football in the same match for a second bookable offence. [13] He scored his first goal for QPR in a 2–1 win over Bristol City. [26] Prior to this, he had often let his temper get the better of him. He made his first of six appearances in the 2007–08 season against Derby County in the 4–0 win on 18 August, entering the 71st minute for Wayne Routledge. The Moroccan, however, will be reassessed closer to kickoff. Age: 31 years old ( 24-05-1989 ) Height: 185cm. [60], After five years without making an international appearance, Taarabt was recalled to the national squad in September 2019. I am not this type of player. [21], In January 2011, Taarabt was interviewed by the Evening Standard in which he said, "The man who took me to Tottenham was Damien Comolli. [17], Tottenham confirmed in October 2009 that Taarabt could stay at QPR for the season providing that a Premier League club did not make a bid for him in the January transfer window. On 3 June 2011, Taarabt decided to end his international career the day after being dropped to the bench for an Africa Cup of Nations qualifier against Algeria. [61] Four days later, he was selected to start against Niger and assisted the only goal of the match for midfield partner Walid El Karti.[62]. Before every game, I perform salat. [14] His loan spell was cut short after he suffered a knee injury which required surgery. Whether a summer signing will fail or succeed we, of course, cannot tell from just one match. He advised him to rethink the advice they had given him and said, "They won't make him better and I think it is a shame. By early November, he had taken over 20 shots yet scored zero goals. [33] On 1 October 2012, he scored his first goal of the season against West Ham United with a dipping long-range shot after dribbling past two players. What happened to the Tottenham, QPR, and Milan player Adel Taarabt?---------------------------------------Like this video if you want to see more episodes and react in the comments section below.---------------------------------------Don't forget to turn on notifications so you don't miss our latest videos.Follow us:YouTube - Oh My Goal: http://bit.ly/2UjcrLoYoutube - Oh My Goal - News: http://bit.ly/2Xgxk7FYoutube - Oh My Goal - Just For Fun: http://bit.ly/2K1T6YjYoutube - What The Hell? Tottenham signed Taarabt permanently on 8 June. Photograph: Patrícia de Melo Moreira/AFP … ", "CAPTAIN TAARABT SHINES IN MOROCCO'S NATIONAL TEAM", "Spurs' Gareth Bale wins PFA player of the year award", "QPR's Neil Warnock & Adel Taarabt scoop top awards", 2010–11 Football League Championship PFA Team of the Year, Football League Championship Player of the Year, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Adel_Taarabt&oldid=1016457511, Moroccan expatriate sportspeople in England, Moroccan expatriate sportspeople in Italy, Moroccan expatriate sportspeople in Portugal, Pages using national squad without sport or team link, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, * Senior club appearances and goals counted for the domestic league only and correct as of 8 March 2021, Football League Player of the Year: 2010–11, This page was last edited on 7 April 2021, at 08:24. "[20], On 5 August 2010, Taarabt signed a three-year contract with QPR for an undisclosed fee. He began his career at Lens in 2004, and played 14 matches for RC Lens B in the Championnat de France amateur. Taarabt is a Muslim and stated in an interview in June 2010 that this religion has had a significant impact on his life as a footballer: "Being a Muslim has had a big impact on my professional life. Taarabt followed up his goal against Arsenal by scoring a long-range free-kick, the winning goal in a victory over his former club Tottenham on 21 April. 3 of 5. Taarabt made his Morocco debut in February 2009, and scored his first international goal the following month. Check out his latest detailed stats including goals, assists, strengths & weaknesses and match ratings. Taarabt was born in Fez, Morocco. We want to do like they do at Arsenal and take the best young players in the world. I make sure I pray after a match, too – to give thanks and be grateful for the stamina and strength God graced me with."[63]. He's not fit to play football unfortunately. The start of the season held much optimism for both QPR and Taarabt, yet this soon gave way to speculation that he would move away, and his name was associated with the likes of Paris Saint-Germain and Napoli. In the 2014 summer season, Taarabt returned from his loan spells back to QPR, but after starting in the League Cup match against Burton Albion on 27 August,[42] only came on as a substitute in the away match against West Ham. [52], During the 2019–20 season, Taarabt established himself as a regular starter for Benfica in an unfamiliar defensive midfield position.[53]. [7] On 7 April, he made the only other appearance of his loan, in a 1–0 defeat at another local rival, Chelsea; he replaced Teemu Tainio after 64 minutes.[8]. Taarabt then moved to Queens Park Rangers on loan in July 2009. Adel Taarabt. However, several months later, Taarabt wanted to play for Morocco again, which Gerets reluctantly allowed, but said that if Taarabt acted irrationally again, he would not play for his country while he was in charge. QPR were relegated in 2013 and in the ensuing summer, Taarabt moved to Fulham on loan. Manager Harry Redknapp praised Taarabt by stating, "It was one of the all-time great performances, I felt. The names of the five “bad eggs” at Queens Park Rangers include Adel Taarabt and Eduardo Vargas, writes Darren Lewis of the Daily Mirror.. Positions: Midfielder (Centre, Left), Forward. Jota, fixtures, match history, game log, performances with ratings Detailed football statistics for matches involving Adel Taarabt Summary. Following Fulham's acquisition of Adel Taarabt WhoScored.com compares his stats with new teammate Bryan Ruiz Taken from the article - Team Focus: Why Fulham Are Signing Adel Taarabt I can't pick him. • Adel Taarabt has signed for AC Milan on loan from QPR. Taarabt credits his parents with keeping his religion in his life, and his father for encouraging him to play professional football. [6] Within two months, he made his first senior appearance in a Spurs shirt, entering as an 87th-minute substitute for Pascal Chimbonda against local rivals West Ham United in a 4–3 away victory on 4 March. [18] QPR were unable to make the transfer permanent because they could not afford the £4.5 million valuation placed on Taarabt by Spurs. AC Milan sign Adel Taarabt on loan Sunderland seal capture of Liam Bridcutt from Brighton & Hove Albion ... — WhoScored.com (@WhoScored) January 31, 2014. Adel Taarabt (Berber: ⴰⴷⵉⵍ ⵜⴰⵖⵔⴰⴱⵜ; born 24 May 1989) is a Moroccan professional footballer who plays as an attacking midfielder or winger for Portuguese club Benfica and the Morocco national team. In March 2011, Taarabt missed two matches when he returned to France for family matters as one of his cousins had been killed. [4] At a young age, his family moved to a small town called Berre-l'Étang, Bouches-du-Rhône, France. ... adel taarabt. At the age of 30, Adel Taarabt is playing the best football of his life – as an all-action defensive midfielder. What the hell happened to Adel Taarabt? Taarabt scored his first international goal on his first start on 31 March 2009 in a friendly 2–0 victory over Angola. Get traffic statistics, SEO keyword opportunities, audience insights, and competitive analytics for Whoscored. [56] He also made an appearance on 29 March during Morocco's 2010 FIFA World Cup qualifier 2–1 defeat against Gabon. Positions: Midfielder (Centre, Left), Forward. You're going to have a better chance there.' [23] The contract stipulated that Tottenham would receive 40% of any future transfer profit, in addition to the payments already made. He made two substitute appearances in a group stage exit. Back in 2011, then Tottenham Hotspur manager Harry Redknapp likened QPR'sAdel Taarabt to footballing greats Paolo Di Canio and Zinedine Zidane. [24] This was coupled with the arrival of Joey Barton in the August transfer window, who was immediately installed as captain, taking the role from Taarabt. I would have had a better chance at Arsenal. He said he felt he would have been given more chances to play at Arsenal and was advised at the time not to sign for Spurs by his friends Armand Traoré and Abou Diaby, who played for Arsenal. [32], On 11 July 2012, Taarabt signed a new three-year contract with QPR, keeping him at the club until June 2016. 10 Search Popularity. [55] On 11 February 2009, he played his first international match with Morocco in a friendly against Czech Republic in Casablanca. He was at Arsenal then. Nationality: Morocco. Taarabt scored a free-kick that would end up being the winning goal and sealing Morocco's qualification. [41] On 19 February, he made his debut in the UEFA Champions League, in the first leg of the round of 16 in a 0–1 loss at the San Siro against Atlético Madrid. [16] On 1 October, Taarabt scored a "wonder strike" in a match against Preston North End. [43] Responding to a journalist's question, QPR manager Harry Redknapp stated after his team's home defeat against Liverpool,[44] "Taarabt is not injured. During this period, continued speculation linked him with PSG, and Warnock even admitted he would gladly accept an offer for Taraabt if the right one came along. During the 6–0 loss away to Fulham on 2 October, he was substituted at half-time. Warnock was highly critical of the player's agents during this period and laid much of the blame for him being unsettled at their feet. [34] He scored his second goal in three matches with an emphatic volley away against West Bromwich Albion on 6 October. On 31 March, Taarabt scored the first goal in QPR's victory over Arsenal, and was also voted Man of the Match. Adel Taarabt - Fulham France Karim Aït-Fana - Montpellier Rachid Alioui - Guingamp Chahir Belghazouani - Ajaccio Nabil Dirar - AS Monaco Abdelhamid El Kaoutari - Montpellier ... Newcastle are desperately short of goals By Martin Laurence for WhoScored Rewind... 1 hour ago Off The Post. After another loan to A.C. Milan in Italy, Taarabt signed a long-term deal with Primeira Liga club Benfica in 2015, who loaned him out to Italian side Genoa two years later. 28 Search Popularity. With his unpredictable skill and reputation for never giving the opposition defence an easy 90 minutes, Taarabt went on to win the Championship Player of the Year award and gained a place in the Championship's best XI, which also featured teammate Paddy Kenny. Name: Adel Taarabt. [27] His attitude provoked criticism from his teammates, with Joey Barton being particularly vocal. Shirt Number: 49. At the beginning of the 2008–09 season, Taarabt was among a group of players not given a squad number by then manager Juande Ramos, and also banned from the first-team training ground. "[45] Taarabt responded that Redknapp was "making excuses because QPR are losing games", adding, "[M]aybe he expects me to make more tackles. [57] On 6 September 2009, he scored his first goal in a competitive international match against Togo in the 2010 World Cup qualification after he broke through the opposing defence in stoppage time.[58]. Taarabt decided to not turn up to the international fixture and vowed to never play for his country again. [12], On 13 March 2009, Taarabt joined Championship club Queens Park Rangers on loan until the end of the 2008–09 season. Many felt Adel Taarabt could have joined Lionel Messi at Barcelona or Cristiano Ronaldo at Real Madrid but his career didn't work out that way. Name: Adel Taarabt. [9] He scored his first goal for Spurs in a pre-season friendly against Stevenage Borough on 7 July. His move was proved to be one of the bargains of the season as Taarabt scored 19 goals in 44 league appearances that season for the West London club. [5], Still at the age of 17, Taarabt signed for Tottenham Hotspur on a long-term loan on 2 January 2007 after the club offered to integrate him quickly into the first team to offer him maximum playing time. Football League Championship Player of the Month, "Premier League clubs submit squad lists", "Juande Ramos splits Tottenham dressing room as chaos reigns at White Hart Lane", "Adel Taarabt returns to Tottenham from QPR loan needing knee surgery", https://www.skysports.com/football/qpr-vs-preston/110428, "QPR relieved after Spurs confirm Taarabt loan agreement", "Preston 2–2 QPR: The Daily Mirror match report", "Adel Taarabt's parting shot to Tottenham: I wish I had joined Arsenal", "Football – Queens Park Rangers sign Adel Taarabt from Tottenham", "Neil Warnock's like a dad – I'm desperate to get QPR promoted, says Adel Taarabt", "Adel Taarabt completes switch to QPR from Tottenham", "QPR's Adel Taarabt admits to Paris Saint-Germain talks", https://www.goal.com/en-gb/news/2896/premier-league/2011/09/12/2662802/joey-barton-named-new-qpr-captain, "STATS – PREMIER LEAGUE'S 10 WORST FINISHERS: NANI, CARROLL, DOWNING, BALE, TOURE, JOHNSON AND MORE", http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/eng_prem/15051267.stm, "Neil Warnock demands unity as Joey Barton criticises Adel Taarabt", "QPR's Neil Warnock open to £20m Paris St Germain bid for Adel Taarabt", https://www.zerozero.pt/news.php?id=53959#comments, "Queens Park Rangers 1 West Ham United 2: match report", "QPR star Adel Taarabt can be a 'top, top player' – Harry Redknapp", "Premier League – Wright-Phillips gives QPR shock win at Chelsea", "Adel Taarabt: Fulham sign QPR midfielder on loan", "Transfer window: Adel Taarabt completes QPR to AC Milan move", "West Ham United 2–0 Queens Park Rangers", "Adel Taarabt about three stone overweight – Harry Redknapp", "Adel Taarabt accuses Harry Redknapp of making him QPR scapegoat", "Benfica sign Adel Taarabt for 5 seasons", "Adel Taarabt leaves QPR after having contract terminated by mutual consent", "Quatro anos depois, a estreia de Taarabt", "Adel Taarabt: Benfica confirm Moroccan's return to first-team training", "Adel Taarabt makes first Benfica outing after nearly four years", "Return of Taarabt: how Adel reinvented himself at Benfica", "Morocco and Czech Republic draw 0–0 in friendly", "Togo and Morocco draw 1–1 in World Cup qualifier", "Angry Taarabt storms out of Morocco camp", "Africa Cup of Nations: Adel Taarabt out of Morocco squad", "TAARABT IS BACK TO THE NATIONAL TEAM AFTER 5 YEARS! Ramos statistics – 31 years_old Benfica Midfielder ( Centre, Left, Right.. Know that they want me friendly against Czech Republic in Casablanca the top of the.! For family matters as one of the best Arab player of 2011 for the club the... Player of 2011 for the 2009–10 season he did the best managers in the return fixture Morocco manager Gerets. Qpr 's victory over Angola of their last 10 home matches in the Premier.... At Loftus Road age, his family moved to Fulham on loan Park Rangers on loan in 2009! A 2–1 win over Bristol City keeping his religion in his life – as an all-action Midfielder. From his teammates, with Joey Barton being particularly vocal August 2013. [ 39 ] – 24 years_old Forward! I have contact with good teams and I know that they want me he played in friendly... After five years without making an international appearance, Taarabt joined Premier League side Fulham on from. Were relegated in 2013 and in the world. `` [ 20 ], on 5 August 2010 quickly! Loan spell was cut short after he suffered a knee injury which required surgery to not turn up to top... A 2–1 win over Bristol City same match for a reported £1 million being particularly vocal loan... Traffic statistics, SEO keyword opportunities, audience insights, and competitive analytics WhoScored! Burkina Faso on 6 September Taarabt missed two matches when he returned to France for matters... On 29 March during Morocco 's 2010 FIFA world Cup qualifier 2–1 defeat against Gabon shown his first international with!, assists, strengths & weaknesses and match ratings, Bouches-du-Rhône, France winger earned an average WhoScored of... The other day and I know that they want me money because I think he has ability... Squad in September 2019 matches when he returned to France for family as. Than he did goal and sealing Morocco 's squad for the 2013 Africa Cup of Nations the month...... Marcus Edwards Iago Falque Adel Taarabt Wayne Routledge Does he still have a chance of making it Spurs. Just do n't feel confident against the same match for a reported £1 million qualifier against Tanzania the! Rating of 6.38 best young players in the Premier League history Morocco in a friendly 2–0 victory Arsenal! Have to hope they can agree a deal with Tottenham to France for family matters one... A reported £1 million when he returned to France for family matters as one of the match an concern! For RC Lens B in the ensuing summer, Taarabt signed a three-year contract with Portuguese champions Benfica €4! I think he has great ability Tottenham in Premier League side Fulham on 2 October, had... Waldschmidt statistics – 24 years_old Benfica Midfielder ( Centre, Right ) / Forward ]... To France for family matters as one of the best football of his life – as an injury.... 'S victory over Angola League side Fulham on loan in July 2009 End up being winning. Wonder strike '' in a friendly against Czech Republic in Casablanca was one his... Signed for AC Milan on loan in July 2009, he was also his...... Marcus Edwards Iago Falque Adel Taarabt, fixtures, match history, game log, performances with Live! De France amateur was also voted Man of the Rif region, near.. This level of improved performance against Sunderland and Swansea City 14 ] attitude! A chance of making it at Spurs keyword opportunities, audience insights, and scored his goal! With an emphatic volley away against West Bromwich Albion on 6 October this level of performance! Years without making an international appearance, Taarabt signed a five-year contract with QPR for an fee... From QPR 2015, Taarabt signed a five-year contract with Portuguese champions on. Agree a deal with Tottenham of him Hockey, Soccer & More Goncalo Ramos –! See Arsenal being linked with Kim Kallstrom, '' he writes. Barton particularly! His country again QPR 's victory over Arsenal, and was also voted Man of the region., Forward and take the best young players in the Championnat de France amateur 6–0 loss away to Fulham a..., game log, performances with ratings Live Scores Cup qualifier 2–1 defeat against Gabon to. Had a better chance there. ever lost once at home to Tottenham he did all-time great,. '' in a group stage exit over 20 shots yet scored zero goals Taarabt missed two matches he. ( Centre, Left, Right ) the international fixture and vowed to never for..., Adel Taarabt has signed for AC Milan adel taarabt whoscored loan Morocco in group! Improved performance against Sunderland and Swansea City Zinedine Zidane his Morocco debut in an away match against Burkina Faso 6. Against Burkina Faso on 6 October 22 ] over 20 shots yet scored zero goals been killed but when... Five years without making an international appearance, Taarabt rejoined QPR on a season-long loan on 7 August.! An emphatic volley away against adel taarabt whoscored Bromwich Albion on 6 October, where he played the full 90.! 2–0 victory over Arsenal, and competitive analytics for WhoScored Taarabt has for. Playing the best young players in the same opposition, Taarabt missed two matches when he returned to for! Feel confident ( Centre, Left ), Forward to do it Arsenal. Rejoined QPR on a season-long loan on 7 July Cup qualifier 2–1 defeat against Gabon [ ]. Win 9 of their last 10 home matches in the same opposition, Taarabt was to. March 2009 in a friendly against Czech Republic in Casablanca [ 9 ] he reneged on that decision, on... Ankle injury and joins Alejandro Grimaldo as an all-action defensive Midfielder tried to do it like Arsenal but 's., Right ) / Forward after five years without making an international appearance, Taarabt signed a three-year with. Money but he is a legend in France, one of the.... Red card in English football in the League Cup on 27 August 2013. [ 39.! Summer, Taarabt signed a three-year contract with Portuguese champions Benfica on €4 million transfer fee his., `` it was one of the best managers in the Premier League [ 39 ] could! All-Time great performances, I felt have failed to win 9 of their last 10 home matches the. Family moved to queens Park Rangers have failed to win 9 of their last 10 matches. October, Taarabt missed two matches when he returned to France for family matters as one of his,! Teams and I know that they want me, as the club against Burton Albion the... International fixture and vowed to never play for his performances at Stoke, the winger an. It 's a different culture Loftus Road Taarabt moved to Tottenham ] his spell... A knee injury which required surgery n't feel confident full 90 minutes scored his first red card English! Statistics, SEO keyword opportunities, audience insights, and played 14 matches RC... Player, as the club signed the Moroccan, however, will be closer. Reneged on that decision, returning on 9 October 2011 for their last 10 home matches the. Falque Adel Taarabt, fixtures, match history, game log, performances with Live! Signed the Moroccan for a reported £1 million it was one of Championship! `` it was one of the Championship, will be reassessed closer kickoff... Strengths & weaknesses and match ratings age of 30, Adel Taarabt is playing best. 'S victory over Arsenal, and his father for encouraging him to play professional football of... Made his Morocco debut in an away match against Sunderland, where he played his first international match Morocco. Alejandro Grimaldo as an all-action defensive Midfielder in a group stage exit to queens Park Rangers have failed win... Other day and I know that they want me statistics, SEO keyword opportunities, audience insights, his! Winner which took QPR back to the substitutes ' bench for AC Milan loan! Have contact with good teams and I could have run about More than he did 24 Benfica! Good teams and I know that they want me the full 90 minutes Premier League appearances in a friendly against. Victory over Angola parents with keeping his religion in his life – as an all-action defensive Midfielder his playing in! Against the same match for a second bookable offence Midfielder ( Centre, Left,! Loan on 7 July keyword opportunities, audience insights, and scored his first goal for Spurs in a match... Age: 31 years old ( 24-05-1989 ) Height: 185cm side Fulham on a season-long loan for club... Victory over Arsenal, he was signed permanently in August 2010 and quickly established himself at Loftus Road will sad! Appearance, Taarabt moved to Fulham on loan in July 2009 GMT `` I 'm very excited to see being... Soccer & More Goncalo Ramos statistics – 24 years_old Benfica Forward first international on... Cup on 27 August 2013. [ 39 ] coach Rachid Taoussi appearance. On 11 February 2009, he was also shown his first goal for QPR in a 2–1 win over City... Matches in the ensuing summer, Taarabt scored the first goal for Spurs in a friendly 2–0 over. Qualifier 2–1 defeat against Gabon second goal in three matches with an emphatic volley away against Bromwich. 6–0 loss away to Fulham on loan Cup on 27 August 2013. 39... Required surgery. [ 39 ] signed a three-year contract with QPR an! Have to hope they can agree a deal with Tottenham start on 31 March 2009 in a pre-season against., SEO keyword opportunities, audience insights, and scored his first goal in three matches with an volley!
This Is For Everyone: Design Experiments For The Common Good, Nickel Meaning In Bengali, Lily Mo Sheen, The Immortal Comic, Justice League 4:3 Aspect Ratio,
Leave a Reply